Maximize your investment's potential

It's no secret that Tallahassee has a competitive rental market. For landlords, it can be overwhelming to price, market, and fill their properties. At First Story Property Management, our team works with you every step of the way while using our local connections and premium marketing tools to get your property occupied with a thoroughly vetted tenant.


Why should I use a professional to manage my home?

Property Management or Self-Management? Here are some of the key reasons many people elect professional management over self-management:

  • First Story provides a fresh approach to managing your home. Our dedicated managers will know you by name and are invested in this company. We understand this is a business built on relationships and reinforced with honesty and integrity.

  • We monitor, understand and apply the correct federal, state, and local laws, keeping you and your investment in compliance.

  • We handle maintenance and emergency repairs with licensed and insured vendors, allowing you to sleep at night.

  • We enforce collection of rents and serve the proper notices upon failure to pay. If necessary, we have the experience to assist you with eviction and collection.

  • We know the local market and have an extensive network of contacts and advertising resources available to us at discounted rates. This allows us to effectively market your home to prospective residents. After you add up the savings with our service, you’ll often make more money than if you managed the property yourself; plus management fees are tax deductible!

  • When you partner with First Story Property Management, you can feel confident that our experienced property managers are taking care of your property as if it were their own.

Do you provide me with a report of activity on my property?


Yes, our monthly reports are available on demand through your owner portal. The report details your rental income received, and expenses if any are incurred, along with copies of invoices. If you wish to have an additional report or have questions regarding your statement, please do not hesitate to contact us.

Click Here to Learn More!

Tell us about your rental property

©2020 Century 21 Real Estate LLC. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, the CENTURY 21 Logo and C21® are service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Century 21 Real Estate LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each office is independently owned and operated. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate. © Website and original content copyright - Stephen Michalakos